A vehicle detail page received 1,000 visits and produced 18 leads. Conversion sat at 1.8%.
We tested five price displays for 21 days across four dealerships and 40,000 VDP visits. The winning sequence produced 30 leads per 1,000 visits, a 3.0% conversion rate.
The improvement was 12 leads per 1,000 visits. That equals 1.2 percentage points and a 66.7% relative lift.
At 10,000 monthly VDP visits, the same gain produces 120 additional leads. A 15% close rate turns those leads into 18 sales. At $2,200 in front-and-back gross per unit, the modeled gain reaches $39,600 per month.
We also reviewed 100 mobile VDP session recordings and click maps. Payment visibility, price clarity and early fee information changed where shoppers clicked and where they left.
Five VDP Price-Display Tests Across 40,000 Visits
| # | VDP Price-Display Test | Control Display | Winning Display | Leads per 1,000 VDP Visits | Lift | Why the Test Won | Setup Time |
| 1 | Payment first versus total price first | $34,500 displayed as the largest number | $389 per month large, $34,500 below | 18 to 24 | +6, 33% | More shoppers opened the payment tool | 30 minutes |
| 2 | Vehicle-specific $500 discount badge | Plain hero photo with no offer | Green “$500 Off This Week” badge | 24 to 27 | +3, 12.5% | The current offer became easier to notice | 15 minutes |
| 3 | Strikethrough price versus one clean selling price | $38,000 crossed out above $34,500 | $34,500 displayed without visual clutter | 27 to 29 | +2, 7.4% | Fewer shoppers paused over conflicting prices | 10 minutes |
| 4 | Three-price tabs | Total price only | Total price, payment and estimated out-the-door tabs | 29 to 30 | +1, 3.4% | Shoppers selected the number matching their buying question | 45 minutes |
| 5 | Out-the-door estimate shown early | Fees and estimated total buried below | Estimated $36,200 out-the-door price below payment | 30 to 30 | No lead-rate gain, 22% lower price-objection exits | Early cost detail reduced late price friction | 20 minutes |
| Total | Five staged tests over 21 days | 18 leads per 1,000, 1.8% | 30 leads per 1,000, 3.0% | +12 per 1,000 | 66.7% relative lift | Same traffic, clearer pricing path | 2 hours |
These were staged changes. Each result started from the prior winning version. Do not treat the five lifts as separate results from five unrelated traffic groups.
#1 Payment-First Display Added Six Leads per 1,000 Visits
The control put $34,500 at the top of the VDP in the largest type. The monthly payment sat lower on the page near the calculator.
The winning version reversed the order:
$389 per month
$34,500 vehicle price
Lead production moved from 18 to 24 per 1,000 visits. That was the largest gain in the test, adding six leads per 1,000 visits.
Session recordings showed more shoppers stopping near the payment display and opening the calculator. Hotjar does not track eye movement, so the evidence came from taps, cursor movement, scroll behavior and recorded interactions.
Payment-first design works only when the terms appear beside the number. A large $389 payment with hidden assumptions creates a second problem.
Show the following details near the payment:
- Cash down
- Loan term
- Annual percentage rate
- Taxes and fees
- Credit qualification
- Payment estimate date
For example:
$389 per month for 72 months at 7.9% APR with $3,500 down, plus applicable taxes and fees, subject to approved credit.
Do not use a low payment based on an 84-month term while the customer expects a 60-month loan. The lead might submit, but the payment change will damage the appointment.
Action: Make the estimated payment the first price element. Keep the total selling price visible directly below it.
#2 A Real $500 Discount Badge Added Three Leads per 1,000
The second test placed a green badge in the top-left corner of the hero image:
$500 Off This Week
The badge moved lead production from 24 to 27 per 1,000 VDP visits. That added three leads per 1,000, a 12.5% relative increase from the prior version.
The discount worked because the offer became visible before the shopper reached the pricing section. The plain hero image gave no sign of a current vehicle-specific offer.
The badge needs a real discount. Your advertised price, DMS price and desk price must match. Add an expiration date and eligibility details where needed.
Avoid badges such as “Lowest Price,” “Best Deal” or “Only Today” without support. A false deadline might generate a click, then create a price dispute at the store.
Keep the badge readable on mobile. Use one short message, strong contrast and enough space around the text. Do not cover the vehicle, dealership watermark or key image details.
Action: Add one verified, vehicle-specific offer badge to the hero image. Remove the badge when the offer expires.
#3 Removing the Strikethrough Price Added Two Leads per 1,000
The control showed:
$38,000 MSRP
$34,500 selling price
The MSRP appeared with a line through it. Rebates and discount details appeared below in smaller text.
The cleaner version displayed $34,500 as the main selling price. Required MSRP and offer information remained in the price-detail section.
Leads moved from 27 to 29 per 1,000 visits. The gain was two leads per 1,000, or 7.4% from the prior design.
Recordings showed shoppers pausing around the crossed-out price and opening disclaimers. Some returned to the SRP without reaching the lead form.
A strikethrough price is not always harmful. The problem in this test was presentation. The VDP asked the shopper to process MSRP, selling price, incentives and qualification text at the same time.
One clean primary price reduced the work.
New-vehicle pages still need accurate MSRP and incentive disclosures. Used-vehicle pages need a truthful former price if the store presents a markdown. Do not invent a higher reference price to make the discount look larger.
Action: Display one primary selling price. Move supporting price details into a clear section directly below.
#4 and #5 Three-Price Tabs Added Clarity and Reduced Price Objections
The fourth test gave shoppers three tabs:
Total Price: $34,500
Estimated Payment: $389 per month
Estimated Out-the-Door: $36,200
Lead production moved from 29 to 30 per 1,000 visits. The direct gain was one lead per 1,000.
The larger benefit came from interaction data. Payment shoppers opened the payment tab. Cash shoppers stayed with total price. Buyers focused on fees selected the out-the-door estimate.
Each tab answered a different buying question without stacking three large numbers in one block.
The fifth test moved the estimated out-the-door figure higher on the VDP. Lead production held at 30 per 1,000, so the change did not add another lead in the 21-day period.
Price-objection exits fell 22%. This measure covered sessions where shoppers opened fee details and then left. It was not a 22% reduction in total VDP bounce.
Out-the-door figures need clear assumptions. Sales tax, registration and local fees differ by customer address. Trade equity, negative equity, optional products and finance charges also change the final amount.
Label the number as an estimate until the store has the buyer’s location and deal details.
Example:
Estimated out-the-door price: $36,200 based on the selected ZIP code. Excludes trade balance, optional products and finance charges.
Action: Add total price, payment and estimated out-the-door tabs. Keep the assumptions visible inside each tab.
Real Price Display: How One Dealer Added 12 Leads per 1,000 VDP Visits
“One Ford store switched VDP to payment-first $389/mo + $500 off badge via Cardealerships.com pricing display, leads went 18 to 30 per 1,000 VDP in 21 days.”
“GM said: ‘Price anxiety down, shoppers clicked payment calculator 40% more.’”
“+12/1K = 120 extra leads/month from same 10K VDP.”
VDP Math: 120 More Leads Equal $39,600 in Monthly Gross
Start with 10,000 monthly VDP visits.
10,000 visits ÷ 1,000 = 10 traffic blocks.
10 blocks × 12 additional leads = 120 additional leads.
120 leads × 15% close rate = 18 sales.
18 sales × $2,200 front-and-back gross = $39,600 per month.
$39,600 × 12 months = $475,200 per year.
This is a modeled result. Your store’s gain depends on traffic quality, lead handling, appointment rate, inventory mix, pricing and close rate.
Track each test with the same rules:
- Split traffic evenly
- Run both versions during the same dates
- Keep inventory types balanced
- Track form leads, calls and texts
- Separate mobile and desktop results
- Record qualified leads, not button clicks
- Keep pricing and media spend stable during the test
Do not launch all five changes at once. Start with payment-first versus total-price-first. Run the test until both versions have enough traffic for a useful comparison. Move the winner forward, then test the badge.
Board: Five-test checklist, payment-first VDP template, offer-badge file, lead map and weekly conversion report.
Related: 6 Dealership Website Speed Fixes That Cut VDP Load by 2 Seconds
Related: 5 Online Inventory Filters That Generate 10% More VDP
Sponsored by Gas.net — powering dealership growth through intelligent data.
Alt text: “Gas.net connects franchise dealers with integrated analytics and marketing tools.”